The Myth: Good Girls are Happy at the End of the Story

You Are Here NowIt’s not that I’ve had a bad life. But I’m not exactly thrilled with where I find myself.

I spent my childhood out of trouble, making friends, but not the wrong ones. I spent school days working my brain, but not challenging authority. I went to a really “good” college, got a glimpse of freedom, but followed the conservative lessons of my parents and got married, had kids and put all my eggs into supporting my spouse. After all, I was raised believing that this was the right choice.

I was a good wife, a good mother, a good citizen. Hell, I’d say I was great. I volunteered at church, at the kids’ schools, in the neighborhood. I played with the kids, let them get dirty, but made sure they read and ate healthy foods. We tithed and I gave to the needy. I encouraged my husband, never turned him down sexually, never really asked for anything. I kept myself up, worked out, but was always careful not to spend too much money. I picked up odd jobs that I could do from home when finances were tight; I worked three jobs to allow my husband to go through law school without working. I told myself it was an investment in our future. He decided, after law school, that he didn’t want to be a lawyer. No matter, he found a job he liked and worked, and got promotions that moved us around the country and the world. With each move, I’d pack up, uproot the family, and make sure that we landed with our feet on the ground. All that mattered to me was that the family was together and I was a good wife, a good mom, a good neighbor.

At this point, you, the reader, can probably guess what happens next. Well, maybe not the details, but details make the story, not the lesson. Yes– my husband had an affair because he didn’t feel I paid enough attention to him; decided he didn’t have enough freedom, he was undervalued. Selfish S.O.B.  He left for several months to pursue the relationship with the neighbor (oh yeah, there’s nothing classy about that story). I’m left holding the bag with the mortgage, three young kids, no career because I’d been making the “right” choices for my family. Oh yeah, I also get half the credit card debt he rang up trying to buy his way out of his hollowness and into another woman’s pants. I guess I made so many right choices, he had the leeway to make wrong ones.

I still tried to do the right thing when he started to have the realization that maybe the other woman wouldn’t fill the huge, gaping hole in his soul. I put up with every humiliation you can think of to try to save the marriage, the family, and the kids’ sense of security. I found myself tending the pathetically juvenile wounds of a man who had wounded me deeply. He never apologized for any hurt he caused me, just wanted to find some external reason for his choices so that he didn’t have to look in the mirror. I lost every shred of respect for the man, but I still tried every therapy under the sun in blind hope of brainwashing myself back into believing that all those selfless acts, all those smart, wise choices I had made weren’t for nothing and that the marriage could be saved.

I’m pretty. Tall, athletic, big boobs. And although I had never paid attention to advances that other men had made on me before, all of a sudden, I found myself wanting those looks. Wanting to see if that guy would look at me. Wondering what it would be like if I were with a man who actually spent a little bit of time thinking about me, the “good” girl. And that’s when I finally decided to end the marriage. It was the last choice that a good girl ever thought she would make. After all, marriage was forever, right? But there I was, still trying to make the right choices, because I knew that I was so desperate for attention that I would otherwise end up in my own affair if I didn’t get out of the marriage. Considering that by this point I was trying to hide the fact that my husband made my skin crawl just by walking into the room, and that I had tried for four years to regain my respect for him, I finally felt okay with bagging it. It was just the beginning of the realization that all those right choices, stretching way back into childhood, didn’t amount to squat.

I had listened to my parents, listened to teachers, priests, common wisdom and just about anyone who had something to share. Yes, I wanted to be a good girl. I had long ago bought into the idea that smart choices would lead to a happy, fulfilling life. Turns out it was all bullshit. And here I am now.IMG_0618

5 thoughts on “The Myth: Good Girls are Happy at the End of the Story

  1. Sorry about your hard times…however it takes two! I cannot help but think that you played some part in this breakup. You may not know or admit to some of your mistakes also. I am in no way defending what he did. Just want you to be aware that no one is perfect. No matter how much you think you did everything right, you probably did not! We must accept responsibility for our wrong doings as well. Until we do, the bitterness and resentment will take hold of your life.


    1. I agree absolutely that I am not perfect, and that bitterness can take over your life. And although I tried really hard to be a perfect wife, I know I wasn’t. But I was damn good and I no longer believe the conventional wisdom that it takes two for someone having an affair (or any number of other things). He made those choices, as well as the one to not communicate to me that he felt something was seriously wrong in the marriage.

      Does still being angry about some serious wrongs done to me and my kids mean my life is filled with bitterness and resentment? A strong NO. I think the blanket wisdom that it does mean a lifetime of bitterness spells misplaced blame for those of us who tend to already be harsh on ourselves. Much of my day at work, at home with the kids, or out with friends is filled with laughter, joy and gratitude. Maybe it’s because I have finally come to a place where I don’t blame myself for other people’s choices. And a place where I’m okay with still being angry about what he did.


  2. To me, it’s obvious that you’re trying to learn and examine about how you got to where you are now & you’re probably blaming yourself too much. It is not easy to open up & share such hard details about a marriage gone wrong. It is easy to say, as another commented, “it takes two” as in to break a relationship. But what does that actually mean? I believe it takes two to make a marriage work. And you can only do your part. If you were married to a man that didn’t share your morals of marriage being forever, and/or a man who was more concerned with his individual happiness, rather than his happiness as part of a family unit, how can you reason with such a man to convince him that being a husband and father should be what he builds the rest of his life around? You can play the role of trying harder & harder to make yourself the perfect wife & mother. But if the man has his mind set on pursuing his own agenda, being a perfect wife, or imperfect wife isn’t going to make him be a good husband. It sounds awful to feel as though you have to achieve perfection in order to have kept things together for as long as you did. It sounds like a lot of walking on eggshells hoping that this man could find it in him to get over his own ego. You can’t blame yourself for the shortcomings of another. Especially the shortcomings of a grown man.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I believed somehow that I could compensate for shortcomings of my own or my husband just by working harder and being completely committed. It is so hard to acknowledge the lack of control within your own marriage.


  3. I think it makes sense that you have reasons to feel angry. The fact that he carried on an affair with a neighbor when he had 3 daughters at home that might witness or get caught in the middle of it, is not only an act of betrayal against you as the wife, but how could you ever not feel anger againt how crazy disrespectful that was to your daughters. Who has an affair with a neighbor for crying out loud. I mean, I’m sure it happens. But when you have THREE little girls in the neighborhood?! Come on what kind of self serving jerk does that. And carries on for months? He’s lucky you are a good girl & that you don’t throw things at him every time you see him. How do you vent your anger when it does arise? Do you kickbox? Meditate? How do you keep it from boiling over?


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s